Home :: Sunday Sentiments

Sunday Sentiments

  • On keeping Sonia Gandhi out

    Posted On September 9, 2002

    By Karan Thapar

    My father-in-law Anthony Meneses was catholic. He was also inordinately proud of his brahmin ancestry. “The one thing you have to remember” he would say “is that I want to be cremated”. He saw no contradiction between his faith and his origins. He was comfortable with the many complex circumstances that made up his character. He accepted the world as it was even though he lived life on his own terms.

    Dad was a tall, broad-minded and large-hearted man. He could be rigidly principled but also defiantly cranky. He spoke fluent French and Portuguese but his favourite lunch was sambar and idli. He knew the good things of life but he hated show-offs and ostentation. He was pious but he had serious reservations about the Pope’s conservatism.

    I’m not sure how he would have viewed the prospect of Sonia Gandhi as prime minister but I doubt if he would have approved. During his life she was simply Rajiv Gandhi’s wife or widow. I he had lived I can imagine the sort of comment he might have made today. “I love Italy” Dad would have said “but I don’t want to be ruled by an Italian woman.” And then he would have added with a twinkle in his eye : “Quite frankly, her mother-in-law was bad enough.”

    I think Dad would have supported a change in the law to bar foreign-born Indians from high constitutional office. It would not have clashed with his democratic principles or sense of equity and fair play. He could never have accepted Sonia Gandhi as prime minister.

    My views are different. Of the many reasons that could be advanced for opposing Sonia Gandhi’s candidature the fact she was born Italian – or did not change her nationality until 15 years after her marriage – is the least convincing. There are far better grounds for rejecting her.

    There are three broad arguments put forward for barring foreign born Indians from top offices of state. The first is that all the great democracies of the world have similar restrictions. But that is simply not true. America may and so too do

    Mexico, Peru and Argentina although the latter three are hardly countries to emulate. But Britain doesn’t and nor do France and Italy. In fact, Ujjal Dussanjh, who was born an Indian citizen in the Punjab, went on to become premier of Canada’s British Columbia. So when K.R. Malkani argues that an Italian citizen of Indian origin cannot be elected prime minister of Italy he is wrong. He can although it’s another question whether he will be. And when M.G. Vaidya of the RSS claims that prime ministers of Britain as well as their wives can only be protestants he is talking hogwash. Cherie Blair is catholic. Benjamin Disraeli was a Jew.

    The second argument for barring foreign-born Indians is the belief they might be security risks. Perhaps but so might Indians born on Indian soil. Treason, or it’s lesser twin unreliability, are not qualities of blood. They are character traits. After all, none of the Indians so far caught spying for Pakistan has been a naturalised citizen. And the argument that Sonia Gandhi would have difficulty taking hard decisions against Italy is silly. The hardest of all was to give up its citizenship. Everything else would be relatively easy.

    The third argument – perhaps the most seemingly compelling – is that citizenship by naturalisation is different to citizenship by birth. Except in a tautological sense, that’s nonsense. But first the alleged difference. It’s said that citizenship acquired by naturalisation can be revoked whereas citizenship by birth cannot. But the nub lies in the reasons for revocation. If your Indian citizenship was acquired on the basis of false documents or if you failed to renounce your earlier citizenship then, yes, it can be revoked. But in either case that would mean you acquired citizenship by fraud. In other words it was wrongly acquired. That’s why it can be revoked. Not because the government has changed its mind or decided you are no longer desirable. For all other purposes, once acquired citizenship by naturalisation is as solid and enduring as citizenship by any other means. The rights conferred are the same.

    In fact you could argue that naturalised citizens show a greater commitment to their country than those who are citizens merely by accident of birth. They have chosen to become Indians. In an age when most Indians would rather be American or British citizens this is a remarkable choice to make.

    Beyond all this, the main point is that India deliberately chose to be different from America. We consciously opted to treat all citizens on par. That’s not only a virtue but a reflection of the assimilative and inclusive tradition of our history. It’s something we should be proud of, not revoke.

    So, Jayalalitha’s recent outburst, or that of the Nationalist Congress Party earlier, or the BJP’s opportunistic support of both, rely on false arguments. They might have a certain emotional appeal but they’re neither logical nor factual and certainly not legally sustainable.

    If you want to oppose Sonia and stop her becoming prime minister there are better reasons for doing so. Look instead to her general political inexperience, her continuing failure to master politics or perform credibly as leader of the opposition, her fear of interviews, her lack of articulate policies or her inability to express convictions. These are good reasons for opposing her candidature. You don’t need more and you need not look for better. They’re enough for the voters to decide by.

    Perhaps she shouldn’t be prime minister. But please don’t change the Constitution or play with the concept of citizenship to prevent her. That would be a terrible – an unforgivable – mistake.


Share this Video:

Description
  
There are no comments on this sunday sentiments yet.

Characters remaining (3000)


Will be displayedWill not be displayed


Will be displayed

Please answer this simple math question.

2 + 9