Home :: Sunday Sentiments

Sunday Sentiments

  • The PM’s Gobbledeegook

    Posted On December 21, 2002

    By Karan Thapar

    Perhaps he didn’t mean it. Or perhaps he did not realise what he was saying. Or may be he just got carried away. I suppose that can happen to any man who fancies his rhetoric, particularly in front of a sycophantic audience. But these are hardly becoming explanations for the Prime Minister of India, a man of 78, who has been in politics for over forty years and who has been PM for almost five. Yet the only other explanation is far worse : he knew what he was saying and intended to say it.

    First, however, let’s remind ourselves of precisely what he said at the BJP Parliamentary Party meeting on the 17th :

    “eqfLye lekt esa ls cM+h ek=k esa xks/kjk dh fuUnk djus okys yksx D;ksa ugha fudys\ vHkh Hkh dksbZ Ik”pkrki~ ugha dj jgk, fd gels xyrh gks xbZ] ugha gksuk pkfg, Fkk] ,d vijk/k gqvk, gesa fey ds jguk gSA”

    To begin with none of this is true. Several members of the Muslim community condemned Godhara. They did so promptly and assertively. The list includes the Ameer of the Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, the President of the Babri Masjid Action Committee and the Treasurer of the All India Muslim Law Board. More significantly, Syed Ali Shah Geelani, a man the government considers the most intractable and pro-Pakistani member of the Hurriyat, issued a statement on the 28th calling Godhara “loathsome and inhuman.” He said it was everyone’s duty to severely condemn such gruesome killings.

    Now, unlikely as that might be, may be Mr. Vajpayee missed these comments. But on the 2nd of March a fifteen man delegation from the All India Milli Council called on him. And what did they say? They expressed their anguish and concern over events in Gujarat including their heartfelt grief for the Godhara killings.

    Yet the Prime Minister has not only forgotten all of this. He’s gone further. His statement actually claims :

    “vHkh Hkh dksbZ Ik”pkrki~ ugha dj jgk, fd gels xyrh gks xbZ] ugha gksuk pkfg, Fkk] ,d vijk/k gqvk, gesa fey ds jguk gSA”

    Honestly, I’m not sure what to make of this. It seems to suggest more than a lapse of memory. May be the Prime Minister has also stopped reading the papers, watching television or even hearing people speak. Or is it that he expects every single Muslim in the country to keep repeating his or her condemnation so that the miserable and unjustified suspicions some people have of them are continuously allayed? Perhaps he really thinks that an Indian Muslim has to prove his credentials afresh each day.

    In contrast, do you know what the RSS had to say of the killings that followed Godhara, when perhaps as many as 2000 people were raped and butchered in retaliation, often by deliberate and careful planning? At their Akhil Bharatiya Karyakari Mandal in March, Resolution-3 said :

    “The reaction of this murderous incident in Gujarat was natural and spontaneous. The entire Hindu society cutting across all divisions of party, caste and social status reacted. It’s unfortunate that a number of people died in the violence that erupted.”

    Does that not read more like an explanation, perhaps even a justification, than condemnation? They call it natural and spontaneous and then dismiss it as unfortunate. And was Mr. Vajpayee aware of this resolution? Or has he chosen to ignore it as well?

    Unfortunately the mystery of Mr. Vajpayee’s strange utterance runs deeper. Shortly after the Gujarat campaign began he gave an interview to Aaj Tak where he declared that Godhara should not be made a political issue. This was not a casual interview; it was done at his specific request. And this is what he said :

    “mldks pquko dk eqn~nk ugha cukuk pkfg,A pquko dk eqn~nk cukus ls ,slk yxrk gS fd tSls vkSj dksbZ eqn~nk ugha gS vkSj oksV dks f[kykSuk cuk;k tk jgk gSA**

    In fact, in an earlier answer he said something even more significant. A simple but telling sentence.

    “Hkkouk,¡ HkM+dk dj pquko thrus dh dksf”k”k djuk

    So has Mr. Vajpayee forgotten his own views as well? Or is it that, after winning the Gujarat elections in such spectacular fashion, he has no further need of his own high-minded morality?

    The saddest part is that Mr. Vajpayee’s recent comments appear to suggest that by failing to condemn Godhara, whether in sufficient number or at all, the Muslim community brought on themselves the massacre that followed. His rhetoric is aimed not at the murderers but their victims. And his finger is pointing not only into the past, it’s jabbing into the present as well. For he adds : “even now no one is expressing regret, that we made a mistake, it shouldn’t have happened, it was a crime.”

    I’m not a lawyer and this is not a legal point but might that not be construed as incitement? Is there not a real sense in which the Prime Minister is telling Hindus that Muslims owe them an apology which, as yet, is not forthcoming? Suppose some people decide to obtain it themselves? Would they be justified? And could Mr. Vajpayee be cited as their inspiration? Perhaps even as their defence?

    I never thought I would live to hear a prime minister of India tell one section of his people that another owes them an apology. I thought prime ministers stayed above the fray. Mr. Vajpayee, it seems, has descended into the crowd and taken up cudgels on behalf of one side.

    eqfLye lekt esa ls cM+h ek=k esa xks/kjk dh fuUnk djus okys yksx D;ksa ugha fudys\ vHkh Hkh dksbZ Ik”pkrki~ ugha dj jgk fd gels xyrh gks xbZ] ugha gksuk pkfg, Fkk] ,d vijk/k gqvkA gesa fey ds jguk gSA ysfdu vc feydj jguk ;g ftEesnkjh Hkh gedks fuHkkuh iM+sxhA

    xks/kjk pquko dk eqn~nk ugha gks ldrk oks Ik”kqrk dk iznZ”ku gSA mldk ftruk fp=.k fd;k tk, mruk de gSA vkSj mlds ckn tks dqN gqvk yksxksa us ns[kk gS mldk ckj&ckj mYys[k djus dh vko”;drk ugha gSAyksxks ds eu ij tks Nki iM+h gS oks iM+h gSA mUgsa fu.kZ; ysus esa lgk;rk nsxh ysfdu mldks pquko dk eqn~nk ugha cukuk pkfg,A pquko dk eqn~nk cukus ls ,slk yxrk gS fd tSls vkSj dksbZ eqn~nk ugha gS vkSj oksV dks f[kykSuk cuk;k tk jgk gSA


Share this Video:

Description
  
There are no comments on this sunday sentiments yet.

Characters remaining (3000)


Will be displayedWill not be displayed


Will be displayed

Please answer this simple math question.

5 + 6