Home :: Sunday Sentiments

Sunday Sentiments

  • A lesson for the New Year

    Posted On December 24, 2001

    By Karan Thapar

    Every now and then you witness something that can bring a warm smile to your face. It doesn’t have to be a big earthshaking development nor a major pronouncement. More often than not it’s the small but telling gestures that carry greater meaning. As the days started to tick to the New Year I felt I wanted to write about something like this. It seemed the right way to begin 2002. When the attack on Parliament turned our lives inside out the urge as well as the need only grew stronger.

    The problem was what was it to be? I racked my brain for suitable moments from the past but none seemed to fit the bill. They were either too far back in time or too dimly remembered or even too slight to be worth recalling. I was beginning to despair when suddenly and totally unexpectedly it happened right in front of me. It was a simple but significant moment that captured the spirit of human kindness.

    Let me tell it as it happened. But remember this is not a story. It’s the truth and there were several other people who also witnessed it. They may not have known what was happening or why it happened but nonetheless they too saw it.

    It happened on Friday the 14th, the day after the attack on Parliament. Chandan Mitra was celebrating the tenth anniversary of The Pioneer. His party on the lawns of The Imperial was going to be the first big social occasion after the shocking attack of the 13th. In turn that would probably be the only subject as politicians and journalists mingled with each other. Not surprisingly, I was looking forward to it.

    Around noon that day Ashraf Qazi, the Pakistan High Commissioner, rang for a chat. He wanted to know what people were saying about the attack on Parliament. I suggested he accompany me to Chandan’s reception. There could not be a better way of finding out.

    “Do you think I should?” he asked. Ashraf is a naturally gregarious person. Such reticence is out of character. But on the 14th I could understand his hesitation. In his shoes I would have felt the same.

    “Of course you should” I replied. “No one holds you personally responsible or feels anything against you.”

    Ashraf paused for a bit but then agreed. Perhaps he accepted my point or perhaps he saw the evening as a challenge he had to face. May be it was both.

    At 8.30 I picked him up and together we drove into The Imperial. Chandan’s party was outside on the lawn and it was decidedly nippy. There were groups of people standing around scattered angheetis. We headed for one that seemed both central but not crowded. As I scanned the other guests I noticed the Advani family entering from the other side. Mr. Advani was in front escorted by Chandan. Mrs. Advani and the children just behind.

    One by one journalists started to head for Mr. Advani. On the 13th he was holed up inside Parliament as terrorists invaded the complex and fired on the building. Twenty-four hours later he seemed relaxed. He was smiling, laughing and chatting happily. I decided to walk up and find out what those horrible hours the day before had been like.

    “I’m off to meet Mr. Advani” I said to Ashraf.

    “I’ll wait here” he replied. We both instinctively knew that on the 14th of December that was the sensible thing to do. This was not an evening for forced politeness leave aside awkward encounters.

    As I worked my way through the crowd in the direction of Mr. Advani I suddenly felt a hand on my shoulder. I turned to find Mrs. Advani. My eyes had been fixed so firmly on her husband I had not noticed that I was almost upon her. But before I could apologise or even start a greeting she spoke to me.

    “Aapne apne dost ko peeche kyon chod diya?” she said smiling broadly.

    “Mere dost?” I questioned, momentarily fazed by the situation.

    “Qazi Sahab. Abhi to aap unke saath khade the.”

    Mrs. Advani had seen us. Forgetting her smile, my heart sank. I wasn’t sure if this was a rebuke. Would she feel I was erring in keeping the Pakistan High Commissioner’s company on the 14th night?

    “He feels a little hesitant to come forward” I said.

    I was surprised by how I had blurted out the truth. It’s not as if Ashraf had said as much but I knew that’s how he felt. You get to know a person after being close friends for years. I was verbalising his unspoken thoughts. But I was still surprised I had said them in front of Mrs. Advani. Normally I try to be more circumspect.

    If anything Mrs. Advani’s smile grew broader still. As I spoke her eyes seemed to light up and before I could finish she appeared to have made up her mind.

    “Is mei kya personal cheez hei?” she said. “Aur phir aapke dost hein. Woh nahin aate to mein jake unse milti hoon.”

    And before I could respond she started walking towards Ashraf. I followed hastily. It did not take more than 15 seconds but in that time my head was awhirl with conflicting thoughts. Mrs. Advani, the Indian Home Minister’s wife, who only the day before had been trapped inside Parliament by terrorists we are convinced were Pakistani trained and funded, if not actually Pakistanis themselves, was walking to meet the Pakistan High Commissioner. Others in her place might have preferred to snub him or at least keep away. I couldn’t think of another soul – ministers, ministers’ wives or ordinary guests – who would have sought him out that evening. Nor would Ashraf have expected them to. And I know that he would have understood if he had been ignored. Yet here was Mrs. Advani striding towards him, smiling as she did, unconcerned about what the world would say or think.

    The look on Ashraf’s face when he recognised Mrs. Advani and realised she was coming to meet him was indescribable. In fact, for a moment I don’t think he knew how to react. Then he looked completely taken by surprise. Seconds later he looked totally delighted. More than anyone else he would have understood that on the 14th of December the High Commissioner of Pakistan could not have even dreamt he would be sought out by the Indian Home Minister’s wife, at a large public reception, with politicians and journalists witnessing the meeting. Such things don’t happen in conventional politics or diplomacy. In fact, politicians and diplomats would have carefully avoided such meetings.

    This is why Mrs. Advani’s gesture is so special. It was not a political act and it had no political message. But it was a warm human act and much more meaningful. It was the response of a sensitive soul, reaching out beyond the strictures of politics, to show friendship at a difficult but telling time. The easy thing would have been to do nothing. No one would have remarked on that. The difficult choice was to show personal concern at a time when it could so easily be mistaken for something else. None of that worried Mrs. Advani. She consciously chose to put a human relationship above politics, above prejudice and above the risk of public misperception.

    In fact, she even encouraged Ashraf to meet Mr. Advani which he eventually did. Mrs. Advani was confident that her husband would greet the Pakistan High Commissioner graciously. She wasn’t wrong. Ashraf hovered in the vicinity of the Home Minister uncertain whether to go forward or not. Suddenly Mr. Advani spotted him and with a cheerful smile on his face stepped forward and clasped his proffered hand in both of his own. It was a moment when human warmth transcended the cold compulsion of politics. No doubt on the morrow politics would return to the forefront, as it would have to, but on the 14th evening the Advanis had shown there was room for personal gestures and that individual relationships still mattered.

    As we enter 2002 I would like to feel that I might be capable of something similar. But I doubt it.


Share this Video:

Description
  
There are no comments on this sunday sentiments yet.

Characters remaining (3000)


Will be displayedWill not be displayed


Will be displayed

Please answer this simple math question.

8 + 4